The Best Grocery Store Butter Brand Is Rich And Creamy

Whether you are using butter to make one of the viral TikTok butter candles or simply slathering a spread on your breakfast toast, you have undoubtedly come to the conclusion that not all grocery store butter is created equal. In a perfect world, maybe we'd all be partaking of butter that we churned from our own milk and salted by hand, but it's a hectic life, and cows take up a lot of space and resources. Therefore, we are always on the lookout for supermarket butter brands that stand out and give us the kind of superior taste we'd expect at NYC's Quality Bistro, which offers a dedicated butter service on its menu.

On the list of the best butter brands at the grocery store, one consistently rises above others like the proverbial cream coming to the top. That's Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter, which habitually earns points for richness, creamy consistency, and clean, smooth taste.

Irish butter, of which Kerrygold is the preeminent supermarket brand, is superior to bland American varieties due to the rich diet that Irish dairy cows consume. These bovines are famously pasture-fed, which means that they are free to wander and graze on the verdant, abundant vegetation in the fields. These greens include clover, which imparts a delicate, sweet flavor in the resulting butter. The beta-carotene in the grass gives Irish butter its distinctive, pleasing golden color. Furthermore, Kerrygold and other Irish butters contain at least 82% butterfat, as compared to the 80% American minimum. Two percent more may sound like small potatoes, but the additional fattiness in Irish butter makes it richer in taste and consistency.

Unfortunately, Kerrygold commands a higher price tag than American butters, thanks to tariffs on European imports that were first imposed in 2019. In an age of ballooning grocery bills and tight budgets, there's no doubt that Kerrygold is a luxury. Once you try it, however, you will discover that the quality it lends to your food is irreplaceable. In this case, it might be worthwhile to splurge.